Files
feedBack/tests/js/highway_3d_bg_control.test.js
T
byrongamatosandClaude Sonnet 4.6 97799fff37 test(h3d-carve-5): fix test 13 kill + add stale-private guard (test 14)
Toby r1 finding: test 13's body-ref filter let the stated mutation escape
('add _pcNewFn to return only → RED' was actually GREEN), and the cut-4
stale-private-reference class (_pcSync bare ref in screen.js) was also
unguarded.

Fix test 13: drop the && screen.js body-ref condition from the leaked
filter — pure 'returned ⊆ destructure' check. Mutation-verified RED:
add _pcNewFn to return but not destructure → leaked = ['_pcNewFn'] → fail 1.

Add test 14: extract every _pc* symbol defined in bg-control.js (function/
let/const declarations), filter to private (not in the destructure), assert
none appears bare in screen.js IIFE body after stripping imports, block
comments, line comments, and the destructure statement. Mutation-verified RED:
inject _pcSync() in screen.js body → stale = ['_pcSync'] → fail 1.

Suite: 235/235 (c4eebe1 base) → 236/236 tip.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014uZ169yfoFYArXz962g7KW
2026-09-05 09:43:30 +02:00

289 lines
16 KiB
JavaScript

// Class-killer tests for src/bg-control.js — h3d-carve-5.
//
// bg-control.js uses a factory export (createBgControl({DI})) because its
// dependencies are IIFE-scope values that cannot be ES-module imports.
// screen.js destructures { _pcAcquire, _pcRelease } from the factory result.
//
// Test strategy:
// - Source-scan tests check structural invariants (critical paths, DI wiring,
// accessor call site, tombstone).
// - Screen.js wiring tests check the import clause and destructure form.
// - Generic stranded-caller test (adapted from bc-panel.js test 12) checks
// that every _pc* symbol in the bg-control.js factory return is also in
// screen.js's createBgControl destructure — a bare _pcFoo reference in the
// IIFE that isn't in the destructure is the same stranded-caller bug class.
// - Construction-order test: createBgControl call must appear AFTER all DI
// definitions in screen.js and BEFORE createFactory.
const { test } = require('node:test');
const assert = require('node:assert/strict');
const fs = require('node:fs');
const path = require('node:path');
const BG_CONTROL_JS = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'plugins', 'highway_3d', 'src', 'bg-control.js');
const SCREEN_JS = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'plugins', 'highway_3d', 'screen.js');
let _src;
function src() { if (!_src) _src = fs.readFileSync(BG_CONTROL_JS, 'utf8'); return _src; }
let _screenSrc;
function screenSrc() { if (!_screenSrc) _screenSrc = fs.readFileSync(SCREEN_JS, 'utf8'); return _screenSrc; }
// ── 1. createBgControl is exported (not private) ──────────────────────────────
test('createBgControl is exported from bg-control.js', () => {
// Mutation: remove `export` → screen.js import throws SyntaxError /
// "does not provide an export" at module-graph load time → highway never
// initialises; all 3D-Hwy users see a blank canvas.
assert.match(src(), /^export\s+function\s+createBgControl\s*\(/m,
'createBgControl must be a line-start export function declaration');
});
// ── 2. DI params declared (all five) ─────────────────────────────────────────
test('createBgControl destructures all five DI params', () => {
// Mutation: remove one DI param → that function is `undefined` inside the
// factory → every call to e.g. _bgReadGlobal throws TypeError: not a function.
const s = src();
const sig = s.match(/export\s+function\s+createBgControl\s*\(\s*\{([^}]+)\}/);
assert.ok(sig, 'createBgControl signature must use destructuring params');
const params = sig[1];
assert.match(params, /BG_STYLE_IDS/, 'DI must include BG_STYLE_IDS');
assert.match(params, /_bgReadGlobal/, 'DI must include _bgReadGlobal');
assert.match(params, /_bgSubscribe/, 'DI must include _bgSubscribe');
assert.match(params, /_bgUnsubscribe/, 'DI must include _bgUnsubscribe');
assert.match(params, /getVenueSceneOverride/, 'DI must include getVenueSceneOverride');
});
// ── 3. getVenueSceneOverride() called as function (not captured at construction) ──
test('_pcSync calls getVenueSceneOverride() not _venueSceneOverride directly', () => {
// Mutation: revert beyond-subst 2 to `!!_venueSceneOverride` → factory
// captures the initial `false` at construction time; the accessor is never
// called; Venue-active state is always `false` → UI never goes inert under
// Venue; user can "pick" a background while Venue scene is active but the
// pick goes nowhere because Venue owns the mount.
const s = src();
// Must call the accessor (with parens).
assert.match(s, /getVenueSceneOverride\(\)/,
'_pcSync must call getVenueSceneOverride() rather than capturing the var at construction');
// Must NOT contain the raw closure variable name in executable code (bare, without call
// parens). Strip line comments first so the comment-doc in the file header doesn't fire.
const noLineComments = s.replace(/\/\/[^\n]*/g, '');
assert.doesNotMatch(noLineComments, /\b_venueSceneOverride\b/,
'bg-control.js must not reference bare _venueSceneOverride in code — use getVenueSceneOverride()');
});
// ── 4. _bgSubscribe called inside _pcMount ────────────────────────────────────
test('_bgSubscribe is called inside _pcMount to register the settings listener', () => {
// Mutation: remove _bgSubscribe call → control mounts but never receives
// settings-bus events; a style change from Settings page never syncs back
// to the in-player picker; the two UIs drift permanently.
const s = src();
const mountIdx = s.indexOf('function _pcMount()');
assert.ok(mountIdx >= 0, '_pcMount must be defined in bg-control.js');
const mountBlock = s.slice(mountIdx, mountIdx + 6000); // _bgSubscribe ~5200 chars in
assert.match(mountBlock, /_bgSubscribe\s*\(/,
'_bgSubscribe must be called inside _pcMount to register the listener');
});
// ── 5. _bgUnsubscribe called inside _pcTeardownDom ───────────────────────────
test('_bgUnsubscribe is called inside _pcTeardownDom to deregister the listener', () => {
// Mutation: remove _bgUnsubscribe call → listener closure outlives the control;
// after release the stale closure still calls _pcSync on every settings change;
// null refs (_pcSel etc.) throw on first setting write post-teardown.
const s = src();
const teardownIdx = s.indexOf('function _pcTeardownDom()');
assert.ok(teardownIdx >= 0, '_pcTeardownDom must be defined in bg-control.js');
const teardownBlock = s.slice(teardownIdx, teardownIdx + 500);
assert.match(teardownBlock, /_bgUnsubscribe\s*\(/,
'_bgUnsubscribe must be called inside _pcTeardownDom to remove the listener');
});
// ── 6. _pcRelease calls _pcTeardownDom ───────────────────────────────────────
test('_pcRelease calls _pcTeardownDom when refcount reaches zero', () => {
// Mutation: remove _pcTeardownDom() call from _pcRelease → DOM node is
// never removed; the settings listener stays alive; under splitscreen each
// renderer destroys independently but the control never disappears → orphaned
// picker remains visible and partially interactive after 3D-Hwy is deselected.
const s = src();
const releaseIdx = s.indexOf('function _pcRelease()');
assert.ok(releaseIdx >= 0, '_pcRelease must be defined in bg-control.js');
const releaseBlock = s.slice(releaseIdx, releaseIdx + 1200); // _pcTeardownDom ~1040 chars in
assert.match(releaseBlock, /_pcTeardownDom\s*\(\s*\)/,
'_pcRelease must call _pcTeardownDom() when refcount reaches zero');
});
// ── 7. _pcAcquire and _pcRelease returned from factory ───────────────────────
test('createBgControl returns { _pcAcquire, _pcRelease }', () => {
// Mutation: remove either from return → screen.js destructure gets undefined;
// first call to _pcAcquire / _pcRelease from init()/destroy() throws
// TypeError: not a function → highway init crashes on every song load.
const s = src();
const returnMatch = s.match(/return\s*\{([^}]+)\}/);
assert.ok(returnMatch, 'createBgControl must have a return { ... } statement');
const returned = returnMatch[1];
assert.match(returned, /_pcAcquire/, 'createBgControl must return _pcAcquire');
assert.match(returned, /_pcRelease/, 'createBgControl must return _pcRelease');
});
// ── 8. screen.js imports createBgControl from src/bg-control.js ──────────────
test('screen.js imports createBgControl from src/bg-control.js', () => {
// Mutation: remove import → createBgControl is undefined in the IIFE;
// the destructure const { _pcAcquire, _pcRelease } = createBgControl({...})
// throws TypeError at module eval time → plugin never loads.
assert.match(screenSrc(),
/import\s+\{[^}]*createBgControl[^}]*\}\s+from\s+['"]\.\/src\/bg-control\.js['"]/,
'screen.js must import createBgControl from ./src/bg-control.js');
});
// ── 9. screen.js calls createBgControl with all five DI args ─────────────────
test('screen.js passes all five DI arguments to createBgControl', () => {
// Mutation: omit one DI arg → the corresponding param is `undefined` inside
// the factory closure; first call to it (on mount, on settings change) throws.
const s = screenSrc();
const callMatch = s.match(/createBgControl\s*\(\s*\{([^}]+)\}/);
assert.ok(callMatch, 'screen.js must call createBgControl({...})');
const args = callMatch[1];
assert.match(args, /BG_STYLE_IDS/, 'createBgControl call must pass BG_STYLE_IDS');
assert.match(args, /_bgReadGlobal/, 'createBgControl call must pass _bgReadGlobal');
assert.match(args, /_bgSubscribe/, 'createBgControl call must pass _bgSubscribe');
assert.match(args, /_bgUnsubscribe/, 'createBgControl call must pass _bgUnsubscribe');
assert.match(args, /getVenueSceneOverride/, 'createBgControl call must pass getVenueSceneOverride');
});
// ── 10. screen.js IIFE does not redefine _pcAcquire or _pcRelease ────────────
test('screen.js IIFE does not redeclare _pcAcquire or _pcRelease', () => {
// Mutation: re-add `function _pcAcquire()` to the IIFE → IIFE-scope function
// shadows the destructured import; the factory's _pcRelease holds a stale
// closure over the old _pcRefs; refcount goes out of sync; the control
// never unmounts.
const s = screenSrc();
const iife = s.replace(/^import\s+.*\n/gm, '');
assert.doesNotMatch(iife, /function\s+_pcAcquire\s*\(/,
'IIFE must not redeclare _pcAcquire');
assert.doesNotMatch(iife, /function\s+_pcRelease\s*\(/,
'IIFE must not redeclare _pcRelease');
});
// ── 11. Construction order: createBgControl called before createFactory ───────
test('createBgControl call appears before createFactory in screen.js', () => {
// Mutation: move createBgControl call inside createFactory → each renderer
// instance gets its own independent control (refcount broken across instances);
// or if moved after createFactory but before register, correct for
// single-instance but still wrong order risk. This test ensures the call
// stays at module scope BEFORE the factory.
const s = screenSrc();
const bgCallIdx = s.indexOf('createBgControl(');
const factoryIdx = s.indexOf('function createFactory()');
assert.ok(bgCallIdx >= 0, 'createBgControl call must exist in screen.js');
assert.ok(factoryIdx >= 0, 'createFactory must exist in screen.js');
assert.ok(bgCallIdx < factoryIdx,
'createBgControl must be called before createFactory in screen.js');
});
// ── 12. Construction order: DI values defined before createBgControl call ─────
test('all DI values are defined before the createBgControl call in screen.js', () => {
// Mutation: move createBgControl call before BG_STYLE_IDS / _bgReadGlobal /
// _bgSubscribe / _bgUnsubscribe / getVenueSceneOverride binding →
// undefined passed as DI params; factory closure captures undefined → TypeError.
const s = screenSrc();
const bgCallIdx = s.indexOf('createBgControl(');
assert.ok(bgCallIdx >= 0, 'createBgControl call must exist in screen.js');
const bgStyleIdsIdx = s.indexOf('BG_STYLE_IDS =');
const bgReadIdx = s.indexOf('function _bgReadGlobal(');
const bgSubIdx = s.indexOf('function _bgSubscribe(');
const venueIdx = s.indexOf('let _venueSceneOverride');
assert.ok(bgStyleIdsIdx < bgCallIdx, 'BG_STYLE_IDS must be defined before createBgControl call');
assert.ok(bgReadIdx < bgCallIdx, '_bgReadGlobal must be defined before createBgControl call');
assert.ok(bgSubIdx < bgCallIdx, '_bgSubscribe must be defined before createBgControl call');
assert.ok(venueIdx < bgCallIdx, '_venueSceneOverride must be defined before createBgControl call');
});
// ── 13. Stranded-caller: every returned symbol must be in screen.js destructure ─
test('every _pc* symbol returned by createBgControl is in the screen.js destructure', () => {
// For a factory module the stranded-caller class is: a symbol in the factory's
// `return { ... }` that is NOT in the screen.js `const { ... } = createBgControl(...)`
// destructure — the factory vends it but screen.js never binds it, so any IIFE
// code that tries to call it hits ReferenceError.
//
// Mutation: add `_pcNewFn` to bg-control.js return {...} but not to screen.js
// destructure → leaked = ['_pcNewFn'] → RED.
const bgSrc = src();
const scrSrc = screenSrc();
// Symbols in the return { ... } of createBgControl.
const returnMatch = bgSrc.match(/return\s*\{([^}]+)\}/);
assert.ok(returnMatch, 'bg-control.js must have a return { ... } statement');
const returned = new Set(
returnMatch[1].split(',').map(s => s.trim().replace(/^(\w+)\s*:.*$/, '$1')).filter(Boolean)
);
// Symbols in the screen.js destructure.
const destructureMatch = scrSrc.match(/const\s*\{\s*([^}]+)\}\s*=\s*createBgControl\s*\(/);
assert.ok(destructureMatch, 'screen.js must destructure the createBgControl result');
const destructured = new Set(
destructureMatch[1].split(',').map(s => s.trim().replace(/^(\w+)\s*:.*$/, '$1')).filter(Boolean)
);
// Every returned symbol must be bound by the destructure (return ⊆ destructure).
const leaked = [...returned].filter(sym => !destructured.has(sym));
assert.deepStrictEqual(leaked, [],
'createBgControl returns symbols not bound by screen.js destructure: ' +
leaked.join(', '));
});
// ── 14. Stale-private guard: no private bg-control.js symbol bare in screen.js ─
test('no private bg-control.js symbol appears bare in screen.js IIFE body', () => {
// The cut-4 stale-private-reference class: a function or variable from a moved
// module that still appears as a bare name in screen.js (not via the destructure,
// not inside an import line, not inside a comment). If bg-control.js is re-merged
// or a caller copy-pastes `_pcSync(...)` into screen.js, this test goes RED.
//
// Mutation: add `_pcSync()` somewhere in screen.js IIFE body (outside the
// createBgControl destructure line) → stale = ['_pcSync'] → RED.
const bgSrc = src();
const scrSrc = screenSrc();
// All _pc* symbols defined in bg-control.js (functions, lets, consts).
const defined = new Set(
[...bgSrc.matchAll(/\bfunction\s+(_pc\w+)|(?:let|const)\s+(_pc\w+)/g)]
.map(m => m[1] || m[2])
);
// Public symbols (in the destructure) are legitimately referenced in screen.js.
const destructureMatch = scrSrc.match(/const\s*\{\s*([^}]+)\}\s*=\s*createBgControl\s*\(/);
assert.ok(destructureMatch, 'screen.js must destructure the createBgControl result');
const destructured = new Set(
destructureMatch[1].split(',').map(s => s.trim().replace(/^(\w+)\s*:.*$/, '$1')).filter(Boolean)
);
const privateSymbols = [...defined].filter(sym => !destructured.has(sym));
// Strip imports, block comments (tombstone), line comments, and the destructure
// statement itself so the bound symbols don't fire false positives.
const noImports = scrSrc.replace(/^import\s+.*\n/gm, '');
const noBlockComments = noImports.replace(/\/\*[\s\S]*?\*\//g, '');
const noLineComments = noBlockComments.replace(/\/\/[^\n]*/g, '');
const noDestructure = noLineComments.replace(
/const\s*\{[^}]+\}\s*=\s*createBgControl\s*\([^)]*\)\s*;/, '',
);
const stale = privateSymbols.filter(
sym => new RegExp('\\b' + sym + '\\b').test(noDestructure),
);
assert.deepStrictEqual(stale, [],
'screen.js contains bare references to private bg-control.js symbols: ' +
stale.join(', '));
});