feedBack/tests/js/highway_note_state.test.js
Byron Gamatos 36cf77dc44
refactor(highway): carve the 2D drawing layer into highway-draw.js (R3c) (#917)
18 functions, 1,245 lines. highway.js 3,972 -> 2,727 (-31%). The biggest R3c slice: notes,
sustains, chords, strum groups, unison bends and lyrics — everything the default renderer
paints each frame.

━━━ MUTABILITY, NOT LOCATION, DECIDES WHERE A THING BELONGS ━━━

Three per-instance caches came out with this slice, and they are why it needed care:

    _frameMismatchWarned   a warn-once Set of chord ids     (feedBack#88)
    _chordRenderInfo       a WeakMap of chord -> chain info
    _lyricMeasureCache     Map<fontSize, Map<text, width>>

All three are MUTATED. Left at module scope they would be SHARED ACROSS PANELS — one
highway's lyric widths and chord chains stomping another's, silently, with nothing throwing.
createHighway() is a factory (the constitution publishes window.createHighway so a plugin can
build a second highway), so they are lifted onto hwState, which is exactly what hwState is for.

The shimmer LUT went the OTHER way — to MODULE scope in highway-geometry.js. It is a
deterministic xorshift table, byte-for-byte identical for every instance, so sharing it is not
merely safe but BETTER: built once for the page rather than once per panel.

Same slice, opposite directions, decided entirely by whether the thing mutates.

━━━ MY SCRIPT WAS WRONG TWICE. THE GATES CAUGHT BOTH. ━━━

1. HAND-LISTED THE MOVE SET. I listed 10 functions and missed six that drawChords needs
   (_ensureChordRenderCache, bsearchChords, getChordTemplateInfo, _computeChordBox,
   _updateFretLinePreview, _drawFretLineChordPreview). The no-undef gate named every one. The
   set is now DERIVED from the dependency closure — 18, not 10.

2. JUDGED PURITY TOO EARLY, and this one is subtle. I classified _computeChordBox as pure
   because its ORIGINAL body never mentions hwState. Then the call-site rewriter injected
   `fretX(hwState, …)` INTO it — fretX takes hwState now (#916) — leaving a function that
   references an hwState it was never given. Purity has to be judged from the body AS IT WILL
   BE, so the classifier iterates to a fixed point: a function needs hwState if it mentions it,
   OR calls anything that now takes it. That moved _computeChordBox to the stateful side.

VERIFIED. A/B against origin/main: IDENTICAL, zero page errors. The PLUGIN BUNDLE contract is
byte-identical (b.fretX arity 3, b.getNoteState arity 2, both stable references, both correct
under the old calling convention). PERF GATE PASSES AT 1.92ms against its 12ms budget — and
this is the slice that could really have cost something: the ENTIRE per-frame drawing path is
now cross-module. It costs nothing measurable.

TESTS. highway_teaching_marks follows strumGroupBuckets to the new module. The two source-shape
harnesses now read highway.js AND every static/js/highway-*.js, rather than being re-pinned at
whichever file currently holds a function — re-pinning breaks again next time, and a shape
assertion that silently stops finding its target is indistinguishable from one that passes.

node 1045, pytest 2416, ESLint 0, no-undef 0, Codex 0.

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-12 13:00:29 +02:00

169 lines
11 KiB
JavaScript

// Source-level guards for the per-note judgment hook (feedBack#254):
// highway.setNoteStateProvider / getNoteStateProvider / getNoteState,
// bundle.getNoteState, isDefaultRenderer, and the _noteState
// normalization rules. The createHighway closure owns canvas + WebGL
// lifecycle that's too heavy for a vm sandbox, so — like the other
// highway tests in this dir — these lock in the wiring by inspecting
// the source rather than executing it.
const { test } = require('node:test');
const assert = require('node:assert/strict');
const fs = require('node:fs');
const path = require('node:path');
const highwayJs = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'static', 'highway.js');
// R3c: _noteState moved to static/js/highway-state-primitives.js and gained an explicit
// hwState first parameter — it has to, because createHighway() is a factory and a module
// cannot import per-instance state without two panels sharing it.
const primitivesJs = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'static', 'js', 'highway-state-primitives.js');
const highway3dJs = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'plugins', 'highway_3d', 'screen.js');
// Brace-balanced extraction (same helper shape as highway_visibility.test.js).
function extractBlock(src, signature) {
const start = src.indexOf(signature);
assert.ok(start !== -1, `signature '${signature}' not found`);
const openBrace = src.indexOf('{', start);
assert.ok(openBrace !== -1, `opening brace after '${signature}' not found`);
let depth = 1;
let i = openBrace + 1;
while (i < src.length && depth > 0) {
const ch = src[i];
if (ch === '{') depth++;
else if (ch === '}') depth--;
i++;
}
assert.ok(depth === 0, `unbalanced braces after '${signature}'`);
return src.slice(start, i);
}
// R3c: highway.js is being carved into modules, so its source is no longer ONE file. Read the
// whole set rather than re-pinning at whichever file currently holds a function — re-pinning
// just breaks again next time, and a source-shape assertion that silently stops finding its
// target is indistinguishable from one that passes.
function highwaySources() {
const root = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..');
const jsDir = path.join(root, 'static', 'js');
const parts = [fs.readFileSync(path.join(root, 'static', 'highway.js'), 'utf8')];
for (const f of fs.readdirSync(jsDir).sort()) {
if (f.startsWith('highway-') && f.endsWith('.js')) parts.push(fs.readFileSync(path.join(jsDir, f), 'utf8'));
}
return parts.join('\n');
}
test('highway declares the note-state provider slot', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
assert.match(src, /hwState\._noteStateProvider\s*=\s*null/, 'missing _noteStateProvider (provider slot, null = none)');
});
test('public API exposes setNoteStateProvider / getNoteStateProvider / getNoteState / isDefaultRenderer', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
assert.match(src, /setNoteStateProvider\s*\(\s*fn\s*\)\s*\{[^}]*hwState\._noteStateProvider\s*=/, 'setNoteStateProvider must assign _noteStateProvider');
assert.match(src, /setNoteStateProvider\s*\(\s*fn\s*\)\s*\{[^}]*typeof\s+fn\s*===\s*['"]function['"][^}]*:\s*null/, 'setNoteStateProvider must coerce non-functions (incl. null) to null');
assert.match(src, /getNoteStateProvider\s*\(\s*\)\s*\{\s*return\s+hwState\._noteStateProvider/, 'getNoteStateProvider must return the slot');
assert.match(src, /getNoteState\s*\(\s*note\s*,\s*chartTime\s*\)\s*\{\s*return\s+_noteState\s*\(/, 'getNoteState must delegate to _noteState');
assert.match(src, /isDefaultRenderer\s*\(\s*\)\s*\{\s*return\s+hwState\._renderer\s*===\s*_defaultRenderer\s*\|\|\s*hwState\._renderer\s*==\s*null/, 'isDefaultRenderer must be (_renderer === _defaultRenderer || _renderer == null)');
});
test('_makeBundle exposes getNoteState (stable reference, no per-frame alloc)', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
const fn = extractBlock(src, 'function _makeBundle()');
// The bundle field must point straight at _noteState — not a fresh
// arrow each frame (the per-frame allocation the review flagged).
// R3c: _noteState now takes hwState first, so the bundle hands out a per-INSTANCE bound
// view created ONCE in the factory (boundNoteState) rather than the raw function. The
// contract that matters is unchanged and still asserted: ONE stable reference, never a
// fresh arrow per frame (feedBack#254). Assert it is a bare identifier, not an inline
// function expression.
assert.match(fn, /getNoteState\s*[:=]\s*(?:boundNoteState|_noteState)\b/,
'bundle.getNoteState must be a stable reference (a name), not a per-frame arrow');
assert.doesNotMatch(fn, /getNoteState\s*[:=]\s*(?:\(|function)/,
'bundle.getNoteState must NOT be a fresh function per frame');
});
test('_makeBundle exposes getNoteStateProvider as a stable reference (feedBack#254)', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
const fn = extractBlock(src, 'function _makeBundle()');
// Same allocation discipline as getNoteState: highway_3d uses this
// bundle field to tell "provider attached" from "no provider but
// getNoteState still exists and returns null", so a per-frame arrow
// here would both burn allocations on the hot path and could trip
// identity-based guards in renderer code.
assert.match(
fn,
/getNoteStateProvider\s*[:=]\s*_getNoteStateProvider\b/,
'bundle.getNoteStateProvider must be the stable _getNoteStateProvider reference (not a per-frame arrow)'
);
// Sanity: the stable accessor exists per-createHighway-instance
// (alongside _noteStateProvider in the closure) and returns the
// slot, so renderers see a live "is a provider registered?" view.
assert.match(
src,
/function\s+_getNoteStateProvider\s*\(\s*\)\s*\{\s*return\s+hwState\._noteStateProvider\s*;?\s*\}/,
'_getNoteStateProvider must be defined as a stable named function returning _noteStateProvider'
);
});
test('_noteState normalizes provider output as documented', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
const fn = extractBlock(fs.readFileSync(primitivesJs, 'utf8'), 'function _noteState(hwState, note, chartTime)');
assert.match(fn, /if\s*\(\s*!hwState\._noteStateProvider\s*\)\s*return\s+null/, 'must short-circuit when no provider is registered');
assert.match(fn, /try\s*\{[\s\S]*_noteStateProvider\s*\([\s\S]*catch[\s\S]*return\s+null/, 'must call the provider inside try/catch and return null on throw');
assert.match(fn, /state\s*!==\s*['"]hit['"]\s*&&\s*state\s*!==\s*['"]active['"]\s*&&\s*state\s*!==\s*['"]miss['"]/, 'must reject states other than hit/active/miss');
assert.match(fn, /Math\.max\(\s*0\s*,\s*Math\.min\(\s*1\s*,\s*raw\.alpha\s*\)\s*\)/, 'must clamp alpha to [0,1]');
assert.match(fn, /if\s*\(\s*alpha\s*<=\s*0\s*\)\s*return\s+null/, 'must return null when alpha resolves to <= 0');
assert.match(fn, /const\s+live\s*=\s*\(raw\s*&&\s*typeof\s+raw\s*===\s*['"]object['"]\s*&&\s*raw\.live\s*===\s*true\)/, 'must pass through the provider live flag');
assert.match(fn, /return\s*\{\s*state\s*,\s*alpha\s*,\s*color\s*,\s*live\s*\}/, 'must return the normalized { state, alpha, color, live }');
});
test('default 2D renderer threads note state into drawNote / drawSustains / chord path', () => {
const src = highwaySources();
// drawNote takes the trailing `ns` param.
// R3c: drawNote moved to ./static/js/highway-draw.js and gained hwState as its FIRST arg
// (createHighway is a factory — a module cannot import per-instance state without two
// panels sharing it). The contract asserted here is unchanged: `ns` is still the TRAILING
// parameter, which is what the note-state threading depends on.
assert.match(src, /function\s+drawNote\(\s*hwState\s*,\s*W\s*,\s*H\s*,\s*x\s*,\s*y\s*,\s*scale\s*,\s*string\s*,\s*fret\s*,\s*opts\s*,\s*ns\s*\)/,
'drawNote must take hwState first and keep ns as the trailing param');
// drawNotes / drawSustains / drawChords gate the lookup on the provider.
// R3c: _noteState gained an explicit hwState first arg (it lives in a module now, and
// createHighway is a factory). The CONTRACT here is unchanged and still the point: skip
// the lookup entirely when no provider is set — a per-visible-note call on every frame.
assert.match(src, /_noteStateProvider\s*\?\s*_noteState\(\s*hwState\s*,\s*n\s*,\s*n\.t\s*\)\s*:\s*null/,
'visible-note paths must skip the lookup when no provider is set');
// Same, for the chord path: keyed by the CHORD's time (ch.t), not the note's, and still
// gated on the provider. Only the hwState arg is new.
assert.match(src, /_noteStateProvider\s*\?\s*_noteState\(\s*hwState\s*,\s*cn\s*,\s*ch\.t\s*\)\s*:\s*null/,
'chord-note path must key the lookup by the chord time and gate on the provider');
});
test('3D highway captures bundle.getNoteState and overrides legacy hit/miss with the provider verdict', () => {
const src = fs.readFileSync(highway3dJs, 'utf8');
assert.match(src, /_ndGetNoteState\s*=\s*\(bundle\s*&&\s*typeof\s+bundle\.getNoteState\s*===\s*['"]function['"]\)\s*\?\s*bundle\.getNoteState\s*:\s*null/, 'update() must capture bundle.getNoteState into _ndGetNoteState');
// Provider verdict wins: miss => not _showHit; otherwise provider state
// or the legacy fallback (`hit`) plus the pre-hit ghost window preview.
assert.match(src, /const\s+_showHit\s*=\s*\(\s*_ndState\s*===\s*['"]miss['"]\s*\)\s*\?\s*false\s*:\s*\(\s*_ndState\s*\?\s*_ndGood\s*:\s*\(\s*hit\s*\|\|\s*\(\s*n\.f\s*>\s*0\s*&&\s*inGhostWin\s*\)\s*\)\s*\)/, '_showHit must honor a provider "miss" and fall back to the hit/ghost heuristic only with no verdict');
});
test('3D highway captures _ndHasProvider via bundle.getNoteStateProvider (feedBack#254)', () => {
const src = fs.readFileSync(highway3dJs, 'utf8');
// Detect-mode behavior — verdict-window cull extension, chord-frame
// hold floor, and the smart drawNote cull — must be gated on a real
// provider being registered, not on the always-present bundle.
// getNoteState. Capture via bundle.getNoteStateProvider() with a
// fallback to the getNoteState-existence check so downlevel hosts
// (no getNoteStateProvider) still behave as before.
assert.match(
src,
/_ndHasProvider\s*=\s*\(bundle\s*&&\s*typeof\s+bundle\.getNoteStateProvider\s*===\s*['"]function['"]\)[\s\S]{0,80}bundle\.getNoteStateProvider\s*\(\s*\)\s*!=\s*null[\s\S]{0,80}:\s*!!_ndGetNoteState/,
'update() must derive _ndHasProvider from bundle.getNoteStateProvider() with a fallback to _ndGetNoteState'
);
// Verdict-window cull and chord-frame hold floor + smart drawNote
// cull must all gate on _ndHasProvider (not _ndGetNoteState alone).
assert.match(src, /ndVerdictT0\s*=\s*_ndHasProvider/, 'ndVerdictT0 outer-loop extension must gate on _ndHasProvider');
assert.match(src, /if\s*\(\s*_ndHasProvider\s*&&\s*chordTailHoldS\s*<\s*NOTEDETECT_GEM_VERDICT_WINDOW/,
'chord-frame hold floor must gate on _ndHasProvider');
assert.match(src, /if\s*\(\s*!_ndHasProvider\s*\|\|\s*dt\s*<\s*-NOTEDETECT_GEM_VERDICT_WINDOW\s*\)\s*return/,
'drawNote smart-cull provider probe must gate on _ndHasProvider');
});