feedBack/tests/js/play_button_reroute_guard.test.js
ChrisBeWithYou 6dbcc5861b
fix(player): keep play/pause button in sync when a JUCE reroute aborts autoplay's play() (#611)
On the first song after a fresh load on desktop, the audio engine is often
still starting when the song loads, so the song begins on the HTML5 <audio>
element and the engine-reroute watcher then migrates it to the JUCE backing
transport. The reroute's first step is a deliberate audio.pause(), which
rejects autoplay's in-flight togglePlay() audio.play() with an AbortError —
even though playback continues on JUCE.

togglePlay()'s catch then reset isPlaying=false and the button to "Play"
while the song kept playing: the button showed Play during playback, so it
took two clicks to actually pause (one to resync the flag, one to pause).
The reroute already guards the <audio> 'play'/'pause' DOM listeners with
window._juceRerouteInProgress; this extends the same guard to togglePlay()'s
catch and the count-in catch, so a play() rejection caused by the reroute's
own pause doesn't clobber the button. A genuine failure (outside a reroute)
still resets correctly.

Adds a regression test that drives togglePlay() through a reroute-aborted
play() and asserts the button stays Pause; it fails without the guard.


Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01QbexxfTt8q2tAn436MqGWF

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-27 13:16:28 +02:00

70 lines
3.4 KiB
JavaScript

// Regression: the play/pause button must not be reset to "Play" when an
// in-flight togglePlay() audio.play() is rejected *because the engine reroute
// (HTML5 -> JUCE) deliberately paused the <audio> element*. Playback continues
// on the JUCE transport, so the button must stay "Pause" (isPlaying true).
//
// Bug: first song after a fresh load on desktop — the reroute's audio.pause()
// aborts autoplay's play(); togglePlay's catch then flipped the button to Play
// while the song kept playing, so it took two clicks to actually pause.
//
// Same isolation strategy as autoplay_exit.test.js: extract togglePlay() from
// app.js by brace-matching and run it in a vm sandbox with stubbed deps.
const { test } = require('node:test');
const assert = require('node:assert/strict');
const fs = require('node:fs');
const path = require('node:path');
const vm = require('node:vm');
const { extractFunction } = require('./test_utils');
const APP_JS = path.join(__dirname, '..', '..', 'static', 'app.js');
const SRC = fs.readFileSync(APP_JS, 'utf8');
const TOGGLE_PLAY_SRC = extractFunction(SRC, 'async function togglePlay(');
// Drive togglePlay() from the not-playing state with an HTML5 audio.play() that
// rejects, optionally with a reroute in progress. Returns the observed button
// states and the final isPlaying flag.
async function runTogglePlayRejecting({ rerouteInProgress }) {
const buttonStates = [];
const sandbox = {
console: { log() {}, warn() {}, error() {} },
// not-playing -> togglePlay takes the HTML5 play branch
isPlaying: false,
_audioSeekGen: 0,
_playAttemptGen: 0,
setPlayButtonState(v) { buttonStates.push(v); },
audio: {
// Reject like the browser does when a pending play() is interrupted
// by a pause() (the reroute's deliberate audio.pause()).
play: () => Promise.reject(new DOMException('aborted by pause', 'AbortError')),
pause() {},
},
jucePlayer: { play: () => Promise.resolve(true), pause: () => Promise.resolve() },
window: {
_juceMode: false,
_juceRerouteInProgress: rerouteInProgress ? 1 : 0,
feedBack: { isPlaying: false, emit() {} },
},
};
sandbox.globalThis = sandbox;
vm.createContext(sandbox);
vm.runInContext(TOGGLE_PLAY_SRC, sandbox, { filename: 'app.js#togglePlay' });
await vm.runInContext('togglePlay()', sandbox);
return { buttonStates, isPlaying: sandbox.isPlaying };
}
test('reroute-aborted play() leaves the button on Pause (isPlaying stays true)', async () => {
const { buttonStates, isPlaying } = await runTogglePlayRejecting({ rerouteInProgress: true });
// Optimistic flip to Pause happened; the reroute guard must prevent the
// catch from flipping it back to Play.
assert.deepEqual(buttonStates, [true], 'button should only have been set to Pause, never reset to Play');
assert.equal(isPlaying, true, 'isPlaying must stay true — the JUCE transport owns playback');
});
test('a genuine play() rejection (no reroute) still resets the button to Play', async () => {
const { buttonStates, isPlaying } = await runTogglePlayRejecting({ rerouteInProgress: false });
assert.deepEqual(buttonStates, [true, false], 'button set to Pause then correctly reset to Play on real failure');
assert.equal(isPlaying, false, 'isPlaying must reflect the failed start');
});